Assemblyman Mike Fitzpatrick's "Property Tax Protection Plan" addresses this multi-faceted problem head on. At its core is a cap limiting
school tax increases to the lower of 4% or inflation. Massachusetts and, more recently, New Jersey, have successfully implemented
such a cap. Even the governor indicated interest. For those fearing 4%, the cap can be overturned via majority vote, while excepting
spending for capital projects and student population growth. The end result is an increase north of 4% and an unintended windfall.
Responsibility for funding state mandates would boomerang back to Albany lawmakers. Since mandated items would surely remain an integral
part of any curriculum, mandates would evolve into additional state aid. Fitzpatrick's plan empowers smaller districts to pool medical
insurance, which reduces cost without sacrificing coverage. A smart detour has the state providing sophisticated data-mining software
to detect Medicaid waste and fraud. (Medicaid is the counties' second highest tax burden.)
Last year's Suffolk County Tax Reform Commission popped the school income tax trial balloon with a resounding "NO"! According to The
NY Policy Institute, New York State recently ranked highest nationwide for per capita tax. Shifting the burden between different taxes
and taxpayers won't fly. Joe Bruno's Senate bill, "NY-STOP," offers district residents the opportunity to vote away their school tax
altogether. One of its many flaws is the failure to indicate how $9+ billion dollars per year will be replaced. Did someone whisper
"income tax?" As for high costs and corruption? Bruno defers responsibility to a Blue Ribbon Commission. The Senate bill does provide
seniors with relief from the very tax it eliminates! I would have preferred to write more about the Senate's bill. Regretfully, there
is little more to address. However short on specifics, and dodging responsibility for fraud, high costs, and the inevitability of
a new income tax, senators unanimously passed this masterpiece.
Unlike the Senate, the Assembly seems inclined to address issues rather than pursue dubiously deserved kudos. Residents now need to
support their Assembly. Taking pen in hand, and phone to ear, may not be a bad idea. With a comprehensive solution within reach, we
need our Senate on board. Given the NYS Legislature's dysfunctional history, can they pull it off?